The Natural Product Directory 
Your Source for Natural Product Information 
Physicians Formula Organic Wear Eyeliner - Ratings, Reviews & Customer Feedback


EWG/Skindeep Rating:

Naturalness Rating:


Customer Satisfaction:

Overall Rating:

Click Here for an explanation of our rating system

Manufactured by:
Physicians Formula Cosmetics

Information from manufacturer website:

Rich creamy color glides on for a smooth, natural finish. Each black shade features a unique hint of color to define and accentuate the natural color of your eyes.


Eco-blend™ featuring OrganiSoy™ & Eco-Olive™

Organi-Soy™: Helps even out skin tone and texture to restore skin smoothness

Eco-Olive™: Natural antioxidant helps shield skin from harsh environmental aggressors.

  • 100% Free of Harsh Chemicals.
  • 100% Free of Synthetic Preservatives.
  • 100% Free of Parabens.
  • 100% Free of GMO's.
  • 100% Free of Synthetic Colors.
  • 100% Free of Synthetic Fragrances.
  • 100% Cruelty Free.
  • 36.9% of the Total Ingredients are Produced from Organic Farming.

(Available in Black Woods, Black Olive, and Black Night.)

ECOCERT® Certified Organic*

* ECOCERT® is an internationally recognized organic certification that guarantees the genuine practice of environmental respect throughout the formulation and manufacturing of the product. The certification ensures that 100% of the total ingredients are of a natural origin. ECOCERT® is the leading European authority on organic certification, and the standards used by prestige organic brands.

Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Beeswax (Apis Mellifera), Mica, Capric/Caprylic Stearic Triglyceride, Copernicia Cerifera (Carnauba) Wax, Squalane, Oliva Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil, Glycine Soja (Soybean) Oil, Tocopherol (Natural Vitamin E);

May Contain (depending on color): Iron Oxide, Titanium Dioxide, Manganese Violet, Ultramarines.

Customer Feedback:

"...extremely useful to apply and it does not bother my oh so sensitive eyes at all!..."

"...The color is nice when it first goes on, but it fades and smudges VERY VERY quickly...."

"...goes on smoothly with no tugging at the eyelid. I don't know how Black Olive compares against the other blacks in this line, but I definitely like the color. It stays on through the day, but I think it does wear a little...."

"...color was nice, it went on very well and looked great, but halfway through the day I had smudges under my eyes...."

"...natural ingredients in a pencil that takes a point easily although it is soft and smooth. Lasting- probably the best pencil eyeliner I have used...."

--Actual user comments from User Reviews section

far superior to any generic eye liner. It doesn't run and is easy to remove!..."

"...Rich, creamy long lasting color, and after one year of consistent use, I have experienced no runny, itchy eyes even after wearing it for an entire 9 hour workday on the computer...."

"...goes on so smooth and it lasts for several hours with no problems...."

--Actual user comments from User Reviews section

Average Cost:
$9 (+ shipping)

Where to Buy:

Our Final Assessment:

Physician's Formula Organic Wear Eyeliner seems to have mostly glowing reviews from users. The main complaint was that it smudges and doesn't wear well, but most liked the colors, and loved the ease of application, and how gentle it is for sensitive eyes. Price varies widely - ranging from under $7 (on to nearly $15, but most fall in a fairly good range for an all-natural product, and should be a fairly good value. Unfortunately this product is not currently rated in the EWG Cosmetics Safety Database, but it is made with 100% natural ingredients, so it gets our highest "Naturalness" rating. We don't want to give this a perfect rating, since we can't assess its safety, so we gave it an overall rating of 8.5, but this may change when EWG rates this product.